Only rule I have is:
If it sounds good, then do it ![]()
If it sounds real good, then do it a lot ![]()
Only rule I have is:
If it sounds good, then do it ![]()
If it sounds real good, then do it a lot ![]()
A lot of those rules were said to me during my first four years of playing it. I was a teenager in high school when I started learning how to play and graduated in 2020. I grew up liking a lot of the bluesier side of country harmonica (as if my fanaticism for Terry McMillan is anything to go by) and I’m hypervigilant to the fact that a lot of harmonica players like to make up BS about the things and people they don’t understand or like, even to the point of attempting to gaslight others and defending their opinions by using random science papers to claim it as fact. Especially since most of the harmonica community on Facebook is filled with so-called “professionals” who would rather manipulate younger newbies into quitting than actually helping them out. Thankfully, I was too stubborn when I was told to give up. This is why I actually want to help others achieve the sound they want to have instead of telling them what they should be playing because some rando on Facebook/Reddit told them so.
You seem such a lovely vibrant yet lacking in confidence person, that the solution is obvious. GET OFF IT. Social media is really bad for most people especially the young. Leave it alone and you’ll be happier. Block coments on your youtu.be etc. Just post if you have to. It’s exactly like a drug for some people. You get a high posting but the comedown is not worth that high. Give it up. Forums like this are way more healthy. I write this with the best intentions in an effort to lift your mood not in anyway tell you how to live your life. X
It’s amazing how much importance we give to what others think. It seems we all ache for a
or a
when in reality all we really need is to feel good with ourselves. Not an easy thing to do, particularly when we are sold an image of how we should be rather than feeling comfortable with who we are.
This reminds me of something I heard which seems apropos…
We wouldn’t worry so much about what others think of us if we realized how little they do ![]()
Or as Martin Sheen told Charlie Sheen is Wallstreet:
It’s yourself you need to be proud of Huckleberry ![]()
Thanks for the reminder @toogdog ![]()
The “Show Off” thread has veered abit off from what it was originally intended (putting up a post of ones playing). Is it possible to get back to that? Of course comments on the play itself are always welcome. What you all think?
Great idea. However this thread was created when we already had one called What song are you working on?
Perhaps all those wanting to post their playing could go back there.
Look for what your looking for before creating a new topic is always a good idea.
@toogdog thanks for your suggestion to @dblues
It seems like both threads are valid and good for different reasons. Not everyone wants to exhibit or “show off” what they are doing, but we virtually all of us are doing something. That’s why chose the title of What song are you working on?
Doesn’t necessarily have to be a video or an audio. Could just be what you are most interested in at the time.
Harp on
me too hahahah
I went to Dayton for a harmonica workshop event yesterday. There were so many people who I knew from Facebook or YouTube, plus I met Todd Parrott IRL for the first time. This was one of the performances I did that day. I decided that I wanted to do Terry McMillan’s version of “Amazing Grace” for the Open Mic. Before I started playing, I was a complete nervous wreck. It was my first time playing live on my own, so that made me anxious; but also the event was being live streamed, Todd was watching in the front row, and my mom was recording me. However, I managed to ace it. There was one woman who was sitting right next to me and Todd who told me that my harmonica playing actually brought her to tears. I knew I wanted to express my own emotions through the harmonica so that people could relate to it, but I genuinely never thought in my nearly eight years of doing it that I had that much of an influence on others. That was a real treat to hear nonetheless. I hope I can do events like this again because I had a fun time.
It’s kind of funny in a way @danielsmith that I never got to fully interact with the harmonica community IRL prior to the event in Dayton because I wrongly assumed that they wouldn’t like me. Almost throughout the entirety of my almost eight years of blowing the harp, a lot of the harmonica players that I’ve interacted with online turned out to be real jerks or two-faced towards me or any of my friends. I’m actually very timid when I’m not performing on stage, even though I appear to sound confident when I talk about my playing.
I mainly interact with other harmonica players through either here or on Facebook, but Facebook (alongside r/harmonica on Reddit) is the most toxic place for beginner harmonica players and those who don’t want to be Little Walter clones. I’ve been told for years that I can’t have 90s country harmonica influences in my style or that I need to use the same gear as the Chicago Bluesmen to be a “real” harmonica player. That’s when I decided to stop labeling my style because why should I have to completely change who I am just to please other musicians to be considered “real blues” or “real country”? If you’d ask me to play “Juke” exactly how Little Walter did it on the original single, I’d give up right before the intro ends because I’m bound to very strict guidelines and the trad blues artists would laugh at me. However, if you’d ask me to play “Amazing Grace” in my own style, I can do that easily because it gives me enough wiggle room to play around with the song.
YOU GO GIRL !