3 Types of Vibrato

How to Sound Less Like a Beginner

Little details matter

The difference between the sound of YOUR harmonica playing, and the sound of the GREAT MASTERS all boils down to…

tiny. little. details.

The details of how they shape their

:point_right: Tone

:point_right: Bending

:point_right: Phrasing

:point_right: Dynamics

:point_right: Note choice and embellishments

are what makes the pros sound like…well, pros !

To sound LESS like a beginner, first get the fundamentals down. Then, once you have them down: focus MORE on the details .

Vibrato is one of those details that can add so much magic to an otherwise boring note, and learning how to do it will massively level up your playing.

What is vibrato? First let me tell you the true definition:

Vibrato: a subtle, rapid fluctuation in pitch

Here’s the definition of a sound people mistake for vibrato:

Tremolo: a subtle rapid fluctuation in volume

:exclamation: People will often use the words interchangeably, but it’s actually very helpful to be aware of the distinction.

When playing a long note, adding vibrato adds TONS of interest, and even on shorter notes, a couple fluctuations as the note dies out is a common habit of the pros.

On the harmonica, there are 3 methods of getting vibrato style effects :

:one: Throat/Diaphragm vibrato - this is the type of vibrato most favored by the old blues masters, and it can only be done (as true vibrato - fluctuation in pitch ) on draw holes 1-6 (and also blow holes 8-10.)

I find the easiest hole to do this on is -2 :

:arrow_right: Put your tongue near the bending position

:arrow_right: Relax it slightly,

:arrow_right: Employ the “coughing technique”

Using this technique on blows is nice too (I do it all the time!) but it’s technically a tremolo (as it fluctuates only the volume and not the pitch .)

If you’re like me, Throat/Diaphragm vibrato doesn’t come quickly. But here’s a BIG SECRET to getting it: do it slowly with a metronome while experimenting with mouth position . Time very well spent, I can assure you!

:two: Embouchure vibrato - This type of vibrato is most commonly used on bent note s. But I recently discovered it actually can add vibrato to blow notes 1-8 (which I had previously thought was impossible.)

To do it simply move your lower jaw (along with your tongue) up and down . Some people call it the “chewing” technique to achieve vibrato.

Try it on the 6 blow - a note used in blues all the time, but since it can’t be bent, is typically not very expressive. Play it with the embouchure vibrato and notice how you can actually get the pitch to fluctuate ever so slightly! A whole new world…

:three: Hand vibrato - OK, you got me, HAND WAH is not technically vibrato. In fact, while it might have a slight tremolo effect (because it’s quieter when your hand is closed and louder when it’s open), it’s most dramatically altering the tone (from dark to bright).

Still, I mention it here because it gives a pulsating to the note like vibrato and tremolo, and it’s the easiest of the 3 to learn, so a great way for beginners to sound LESS like beginners.

Also you can actually move your hand in a way that gets the pitch to alter. Although this isn’t a common approach, Roly Plat mentions it in his Vibrato Harmonica Lesson, a great resource for further study on the subject. I’ve been trying it, and I think it’s a totally viable approach.

Check out this video of me demonstrating the 3 types of vibrato.

If notes, licks, and phrasing are the cake… vibrato is the icing on the cake . (And who wants cake without icing? :wink:)

5 Likes

One of the first things my teacher and I tackled during my lessons was throat vibrato. I originally started trying to do throat vibrato because I thought that it had such a cool sound to the sound of a harp. When I tried to do it on my own, it sounded more like a volume change more than a pitch change. So I made the switch to cheat a vibrato by using my tongue. During my first lesson with Todd Parrott, he mentioned that Terry McMillan used a throat vibrato when playing. So it was my goal to try the technique again. Now I’m at the point where my vibrato is showing, but I’m just smoothing out the kinks to it to sound less rough around the edges.

2 Likes

I’m working to try to get throat vibrato down so I can vary the type I use depending on the mood or groove I’m playing. Embouchure vibrato just came natural to me since I’ve sang my whole life. To me this technique is very closely related to how you add vibrato when singing.

I always knew the harmonica would be more difficult to play than people think but I never thought about all the little nuances necessary to sound pro until beginning to learn myself (I’m only about a month in). Learning pedal steel was the same way. Just as when I learned pedal steel, I’m gonna dive in and dedicate myself to learning this beautiful expressive instrument. Respect to all of you who play harp!

3 Likes

Hi @MorrisMusic513

With your attitude and dedication I am sure you will achieve your harmonica goals!

Welcome to the forum!

Regards,

– Slim :sunglasses:

3 Likes

@MorrisMusic513 I +1 what @Slim said!

Welcome to the forum! I applaud you for working on vibrato. It’s something I haven’t devoted enough attention to and still needs a great deal more work.

At only a month in, you’re probably gonna wanna focus on just creating TREMOLO using the coughing technique.

One way is to put the metronome on 60 BPM, do the coughing technique once/click, then twice/click, the goal is to see if you can get it up to 6 times/click. I can only really comfortably do 5 times/click right now, and even that not as steady as I’d like.

You’ll find this technique is more difficult on draws than on blows, and also draws are where you can later turn the TREMOLO (volume fluctuation) into VIBRATO (pitch fluctuation) so it makes sense to devote more of your practice time to drawing.

But since we have to exhale, and doing the coughing technique on the exhales I can always go faster than inhales so it’s kinda like telling my body: you can do this! It’s still good to practice the exhale coughing technique, but I’ll outgas heavily through my nose to get all of the air out of my lungs as quickly as possible so I can get back to the more important task of working on the inhales.

Later when you learn bending, then you just add to your practice, pulling the tongue into the position where it bends the note. The trick is to have the tension in your tongue needed to create the pitch change, but keep it relaxed enough that the coughing technique will pull it and release it for the fluctuation.

3 Likes

Yes I am certainly working on tremolo however by raising and lowering the floor of my mouth (with my tongue, like when you say “yoyo”) I’m getting a nice fluctuation in pitch. I’ve been using the bending tool you have on the website and watching to see what kind of pitch fluctuation I’m getting. No it isn’t as deep as the throat or diaphragm vibrato I hear guys using, but it is indeed a shift in the pitch not just the volume, so I’m content with it for now. Yes it’s only really noticeable on bendable notes but even the n notes that don’t bend (hole 5 for example) I can get the pitch to go just slightly flat, but only barely.

I’ve been using my hands mostly for tremolo but Im going to use the metronome and try it as you suggest (5-6 times per beat @ 60 bpm).

I appreciate this website, this forum and all the videos. The work that all the guys have put in is no less than remarkable. Thanks Luke, Slim and all the other guys.

3 Likes

@MorrisMusic513 yeah it sounds like you’re talking about what’s referred to as “chewing vibrato.” Moving the jaw (which moves the tongue.)

This vibrato is much easier to control than the throat vibrato, and as you mention you can get. a little bit of pitch fluctuation on some notes that don’t bend - notably the blow 6. If you’re really gentle, you can even get pitch fluctuation on some of the draws -7 through -10 (you just have to be very gentle.)

And of course you can get great pitch fluctuation on all the draws -1 through -6 and on the blows 7-10.

But the throat vibrato that I was describing of course is a much deeper, more visceral vibrato that’s used often in blues.

Glad the resources are helping. Happy you’re part of the community. Rock on! :sunglasses:

3 Likes

Chewing vibrato…. I’ve not run across that before now. I love the depth of throat vibrato and want to work towards that eventually That said I want to get my bends mastered along with the other fundamental techniques. Thanks again Luke.

3 Likes

Great, as always. Have I seen a vibrato by moving the jaw side to side and perhaps the tongue, or is that called something else? If there is such a move, where could it be used? Thanks.

1 Like

Moving the jaw (as you describe it) is done to move between two adjacent holes on the harp. This results in playing different notes, which is not a vibrato. It can sometimes be used as an alternative to moving the harp or your head. Some harpists use it quite frequently, others not so often.

2 Likes

Okay. Thanks Slim

3 Likes

Butterfield was a master of vibrato I always tell anyone who wants to learn it listen to him.