How to Get Better... Without Even Practicing (Active Listening)

How to Get Better… Without Even Practicing
600x400

The most fundamental skill musicians need to develop is listening.

Spending time practicing the harmonica isn’t the only way to improve on the instrument. An equally important activity is active listening.

When you learn to active listen you’ll find this happens:

:+1: You play the right thing because you hear how your playing fits into the whole.

:+1: You start to be able to grow your musicianship anytime you hear music.

:+1: While playing along with a song, you don’t get lost as easily.

:+1: It becomes easier to learn songs by ear.

:+1: You get better at improvising.

There are LOTS of ways to LISTEN ACTIVELY.

:ear:t3::notes::sunglasses:

The most challenging, and rewarding, thing is to transcribe something to memory, which is what people often refer to as “learning by ear”. I’ve already written about learning by ear, but here’s a quick recap:

:arrow_right: You can learn anything, as long as you can slow it down enough. So if you want to transcribe to memory, your first order of business is to find a tool to slow down your audio.

On the desktop I use Transcribe!, and on my phone I use the Amazing Slow Downer. Next, you have to make sure you have the right key harmonica to learn the song you are wanting to learn. If you’re a total beginner and you’re unsure how to do this, just post a question in the forum and we’ll get you sorted!

:arrow_right: Next, play the first note on your device, press pause, sing it, and play a note on the harmonica. If it’s lower than the note you sang, try a higher note on the harmonica, and vice versa, until the note you are singing and the note you are playing match.

It might take you many minutes to find that note on the harmonica, but I assure you it’s time well spent!

:arrow_right: Next, play the first and second note on your device. Sing them, and then try to play them on the harmonica.

This might sound overwhelming, but it’s the real deal. This is how all of our harmonica heroes learned the instrument (except we have better tools to slow down audio now).

Transcribing 3 notes to memory this way,

WILL GROW YOUR SKILLS MORE than

learning 3 entire songs looking at tabs.

And like anything, the more you do it,

the better you will get at it!

That’s why I’ve often said that the best way to take my Beginner to Bosscourse is with your eyes closed!

But besides transcribing, there’s TONS of other ways to listen activelywhich you can do anytime, anyplace that music is playing. Here’s a few ideas to get you started:

:point_right: Hear the time signature. Tap your foot or your hand to the beat, and count. Most popular songs you’ll find that you count to 4 over and over again, but some you might find 3 or 6. Note: beat 1 of each bar naturally feels the strongest accent.

:point_right: Hear the form. Here are a few common forms:

:small_blue_diamond: Verse, Chorus, Verse, Chorus, Verse, Chorus

:small_blue_diamond: Verse, Chorus, Verse, Chorus, Bridge, Chorus

But some songs start with the Chorus. Some songs start with an instrumental or have a solo. The 12-Bar Blues has an AAB form. Noticing the form of the songs is a great form of active listening. Write down the form of your favorite song. Soon you’ll start hearing forms naturally.

:point_right: Count bars. How many bars are in each section of the song? Is the chorus 8 bars or 16 bars? Maybe the first verse is 16 bars, but the second verse is only 8 bars. If the song has 4 beats / bar, simply count to 4: “1, 2, 3, 4” and then replace “1” with the bar number, like this:

:small_blue_diamond: 1, 2, 3, 4

:small_blue_diamond: 2, 2, 3, 4

:small_blue_diamond: 3, 2, 3, 4

:small_blue_diamond: 4, 2, 3, 3

:point_right: Hum the Bass. Can you hum the root note of the chords being played? If you’re in the process of learning/memorizing the 12-Bar Blues form, this exercise can work wonders! But it’s a great exercise to practice on anytune.

:point_right: Hear instrumentation. What instruments are in the mix? Is it an upright bass or an electric bass? Acoustic guitar or electric guitar? As you practice this, you will notice certain instruments only appear in certain sections of the song. Maybe an electric guitar, a tambourine, or an organ only appears in the choruses, but not in the verses. Maybe the drummer switches from playing the hi-hat to playing the ride cymbal.

:point_right: Map the Sound Stage. This exercise takes hearing instrumentation to the next level. Place instruments where they exist in the sound stage from left to right and from front to back. Louder instruments closer to the front and quieter instruments further back, and where do they sit in the mix from left to right.

Typically, bass, kick drum, snare, and vocals are right up the middle, and other instruments are panned off to one side or the other. This kind of exercise is much more difficult to do with dense mixes with lots of instruments like large orchestras or big afro-cuban ensembles.

:point_right: Hear the Harmonica. As a beginner this is difficult, but the longer you play, and the more you learn the easier it becomes. If you’ve been playing for a while you can probably at least recognize the -45 trill. Are they playing chords, single notes, or splits? Are they bending?

10 Likes

@Luke You’ve put into words what probably many musicians do without realising they are doing it, in time it becomes second nature. What’s your take on tabs. is there too much reliance on them? I use tabs or dots for the first few lines only to get the memory of a tune into my head, after that it’s playing by ear. Some of the people I’ve worked with are lost if they don’t have dots or tabs and their playing seems to be stilted, what’s your view? On another tack how are you doing with the Bushman Game Changers? I’d quite like to try their solo tuned models, which tuning did you go for? Jay1

1 Like

@Luke when I read the title I laughed thinking “Luke has found some magic for me to get better by sitting in my sofa eating potato chips?” :rofl:

2 Likes

That’s great Luke and pretty much how I learned, there were no Lessons available back then, I was lucky enough to have a few famous muso friends that gave me tips but mostly it was listening over and over, when CDs came out I was able to stop ruining my vinyl and stop and start the song where I got stuck. Prior to that I was also using cassette tapes too but my tape player was cannibalistic, but I find this much easier than harmonica tab. I’m autistic I’m high functioning I have Asperger’s the thing is I’m not a mathematical genius like some autistic people can be, my autistic talent is artistic and musical. I get very confused by numbers so tab doesn’t work for me. I find that very frustrating tried and true methods of listening and learning are best for me

3 Likes

@Jay1 I got the standard diatonic tuning since that’s what I’m used to. Haven’t been playing them much. They’re cool though! Just ask @Hogie.Harmonica. He literally wrote a whole book about them!!! (Ask on the GameChanger thread though - not here!)

@Mugen Yes! You can eat potato chips while practicing active listening. :wink:

2 Likes

Hey Jay,

The blue game changers are tuned the same as a regular blues harp. But if you push in the slide, you get a 2nd blues harp. They are a half-step higher. So if you have a C harp, pushing in the slide gives you a Db harp.

You can use these to just reduce the number of harps you carry, but the best way to use them is to “steal” notes from the slide-in “harp”.

Middle octave is identical to Solo tuning, which is the standard tuning for a chromatic harmonica. So if you focus on the middle octave, eventually you can transfer that learning to a regular chromatic (or the yellow solo tuned Trochilus, if you want).

As for relying on tabs - it really depends on your goals. If you want to pick out a tune once in awhile, there’s nothing wrong with tabs. If you want to become a musician, it is very much worth your time to learn to read music. Many ways to go about this, but the main thing is 1) use materials designed to help you learn to read music. Get some that go very, very slow. Because it takes a little more effort to learn to read music on harp because you can’t see the notes. 2) Work with a teacher who can read music.

If you do that and get good at it, it will open doors you never imagined you could walk through. I know it has for me.

1 Like

@Hogie.Harmonica Hi Hogie, I’m a full-time lawyer and part-time session player at a recording studio. I can sight read music but prefer not to as the music seems stilted and I prefer to improvise, probably from an early jazz background. I only use solo tuned chromatics these days and if playing blues play 3rd position. I wasn’t aware that the Game Changers are Richter tuned the same as a diatonic harp, I think I’ll stick to solo tuned chromatics, I’ve enough things messing with my head without changing a familiar tuning but thanks for the heads up.Jay1

The Trochilus does come in solo tuning, I have one in C and one in A. So far, nice for practicing in the cold. They are much more airtight than my Forerunners, and smaller. Chest pocket works well.

They do overblow well in the middle and top octave. Low octave, I may have more to learn before forming an opinion.

@Hogie.Harmonica Thanks I’ll have a look when I’m back, presently away doing a complex legal case and afterwards (if the case concludes on time) I’ll be racing one or possibly two of the cars at the Goodwood classics meeting so busy time. Jay1