Natural Minor Will Explode Your Harp Game (+ Natural Mystic on Am w/Tabs)

Natural Minor Will Explode Your Harp Game

Standard tuned harps are awesome. MOST of the time I play standard 10-hole diatonic harmonicas.

When we say “Standard tuned harp” we are referring to the Richter tuning, named after the 19th century harmonica maker Joseph Richter:

Blow holes play the chord in the key of the harmonica, and draw holes 1-4 play the dominant V7 chord (a G chord on a C harmonica). The major scale in the key of the harmonica is played between holes 4 and 7.

:point_right: They are GREAT for folk music (which is what they were originally designed for in early 19th century Europe) in FIRST POSITION - playing in the key of the harmonica (Key of C on a C harmonica).

:point_right: And they are GREAT for the blues (which the Americans discovered/innovated in the early 20th century) in SECOND POSITION - playing up 5 note names from the key of the harmonica (Key of G on a C harmonica).

:point_right: But they also limit the genres you can play.

Even for players who master the other positions and advanced techniques necessary to play certain melodies, we still don’t have the chords that the Natural Minor harmonicas provide.

This is where a Natural Minor harp can step up to the plate.

Natural Minor harmonicas are labeled and designed to be played in 2nd position.

So a G Natural Minor is just like a C Harmonica:

:small_blue_diamond: C Diatonic Harmonica = Draw chord G, Blow chord C

:small_blue_diamond: G Natural Minor = Draw chord G minor, Blow chord C minor

:arrow_right: 1st position our most important notes are blows

:arrow_right: 2nd position our most important notes are draws

The benefit that can explode your harp game? Natural Minor harps have a very bluesy, soulful sound that’s perfect for playing Minor Blues, Reggae, Ska, Latin, Funk, R & B, Hip Hop. (You can hear me soloing on a Natural Minor harmonica on this hip hop track.)

You can play minor melodies in 3rd, 4th, and 5th position on a standard tuned harmonica. But the awesome thing about the Natural Minor is you can play everything you normally play in 2nd position, just now it sounds minor.

For example, the Bob Marley song Natural Mystic in A minor could be played in 3rd position on a G harmonica, but using an A Natural Minor harp, WE CAN PLAY THE CHORDS and also, all of our fun 2nd position licks, like the -45 trill. Check out this vid.

Here’s how I’m playing the chords

:point_right: The i Chord, A minor, -123

:point_right: The iv Chord, D minor, 1234

:point_right: The v Chord, E minor, I’m playing -145 (covering holes -23 with my tongue, but you could just play -45 for the v Chord.)

Here’s the tabs for Natural Mystic by Bob Marley on an Am Natural Minor:

-2 -3 4 4 4 -4 -3 -2 -2 -2" -2 (repeat)

-2 -3 4 -3 4 -3 -2

-4 -5 5 -3 4 -4

-2 -3 4 -3 4 -4 -3 -2

-2 -3 4 -3 -4’ -4 -3’ -3

-3 -3’ 4 -3

-2 -3 4 4 4 -4 -3 -2 -2 -2" -2

As you can see in this video, I’m taking advantage of all of the things I love about playing in 2nd position, like the -45 trill. I LOVE playing Lee Oskar Natural Minor Harmonicas!

11 Likes

Awesome! This is so great, I have just never thought of harmonica in reggae before. Now new wonderful opportunities open up.
When I am a bit up to speed on my harping and can isolate notes a bit better, I’ll come back to this!

4 Likes

Right on @pakehall I thought you would dig this! Yeah the Natural Minor harps are great fun because you can play any kind of 2nd position groove you’d play on a standard tuning, and everything translates over exactly, now it just sounds minor. Great for playing reggae, even just reggae chords/rhythms!

2 Likes

Here’s some footage from a recent gig playing I Shot the Sheriff on a Natural Minor harmonica. Using a key of Gm here:

6 Likes

I will get there at some point. Still rocking module 2 of the B2B course. LOL

2 Likes

Nice article brah :call_me_hand:

1 Like

You get yours yet?

1 Like

I’m getting close to pulling the trigger. I go to the states in two weeks. I have a Harmo in Gm in my cart which looks so purty. It’s red comb differentiates it from standard D tuning black combs. . I really like my Harmo in B, so I think I’ll go that route.

I’m excited to play it… I never thought about something you said in the video. Anything played on the standard tuning can be played on the minor harmonica with a minor feel.

I can sense an Am in my future :crystal_ball: as well. I foresee a Lee Oskar perhaps for Christmas . :smiling_face_with_sunglasses: Also Am is such an easy key to play on the piano :musical_keyboard:

1 Like

Wow, @Luke this article blew my mind! I had no idea that natural minor key tuning was essentially the same as major key tuning for 2nd position! A game changer! I’m getting a natural minor Lee Oskar soon!

2 Likes

@Luke,

Question: What do you think of Will Wilde’s harps for the blues? I recently saw that his online store has minor key harmonicas in his own special tuning. He says they are tuned for rock music (I play both blues and rock). but I just saw a YouTube video of Wilde’s performance of Sonny Boy Williamson’s “Help Me,” and he used his own C major tuning on a Seydel 1847 Classic harp (https://youtu.be/abkT5XQ6xkA?is=xDYMAIglavJ2ViW2).. Sounds bluesy to me (though it seems more “clean” than “dirty” or distorted). He sells the minor-tuned harps in Seydel Session Steel.

What do you think about Wilde’s tuning for classic blues?

Thanks very much!

1 Like

@Jim3Mix sure Will wild tuning will work fine for classic blues! I’m not really a fan of Seydel Harmonica’s personally. Will’s tuning is especially good for emulating fast guitar riffs - specifically it allows you to get from the draw five to the six faster. (cos you can bend into in his tuning.)

That has never been important enough to me to adopt the tuning.

The only alternate tuning that I have really adopted a lot for blues playing is the Parrott tuning to make it quick and easy to get that minor third above the octave in second position.

1 Like

Good to know! I’ve heard of Parrot tuning but don’t know anything about it. I will check it out.

Thanks very much!

1 Like

It’s relatively easy to modify a regular blues harp to convert it into one with Todd Parrott tuning – but once you have done that, it is best to leave it that way and NOT try to convert it back again because the modified reed will fail rather quickly after so much grinding. :backhand_index_pointing_left:

2 Likes

Thanks very much, @Carlos1 !

2 Likes

I got my first Minor tuned harp :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

I was originally disappointed :face_with_diagonal_mouth: because I couldn’t get the two draw to work. After a similar problem on un boxing my LO in A a while back, I opened her up and was finally able to get it wiggling as it should.

I love it!

Being able to get the flattened third without a bend is really cool. Several songs I had difficulty playing in the lower octave now come super smooth, like Stairway to Heaven.

I am pleasantly surprised to find the Cm scale accessible up and down the harp. Though it is in Dorian mode, a small bend on the six draw gets the Natural minor note in the middle octave and the low end a - 2" and a - 3" gets the full scale (similar to the major scale Ona standard diatonic harp)

In particular, I love being able to a C Minor arpeggio up and down the harp with easy blows.

I’m still experimenting with giving major songs a minor feel. For now it just sounds like I’m playing the song wrong in most cases.

I’m glad I stuck to my guns with this harp. I was about to return it and buy a Hohner Pentaharp. Fortunately, I saw @Luke s video advising against doing so!

After my initial difficulty with the 2 draw, she bends nicely and has a similar quality in the tone as my Golden Melody in C. This is my second Harmo Polar harp.

Here is the song I bought it for, accompanied by the piano :musical_keyboard:

:backhand_index_pointing_down: :backhand_index_pointing_down:

On Our Way in Gm

2 Likes

@HarpinBobbyMcB,

Good to hear that you are enjoying the minor blues. Based on @Luke’s recommendation, I bought an A minor harp (this time from East Top, though Lee Oskar is my favorite). I just got it, so I haven’t tried it yet on any of my songs; I will take your advice and try it on Stairway to Heaven. Looking forward to that! :musical_score::musical_notes::musical_note:

2 Likes

I believe A minor should be the right key for Stairway to Heaven. Let us know how it goes. Sounds super cool in Gm too.

I can feel an Am in my future :crystal_ball:

2 Likes

@Jim3Mix @HarpinBobbyMcB wondering if your harps are labeled in 1st position (blow chord is key label) or 2nd position (draw chord is key label)?

3 Likes

Mine is on the draw :backhand_index_pointing_down:

Here are a few more pics. She’s quite a looker!


Here she is beside her brother B :backhand_index_pointing_down:


1 Like

@Luke,

I don’t have it with me right now to take a pic, but it’s labeled “Am” on the short side (“around the corner” from the 1-hole).. Also doesn’t have the “N” like @HarpinBobbyMcB’s.

I didn’t know a harp could be labeled either for the 1-position or 2-position key. Does this happen only with the minor keys or maybe it depends on the manufacturer?

1 Like